Repayment · 9 min read
7 Ways to Fix Student Loans and the Trade-offs of Each
Seven policy ideas for federal student loans, set against what the 2025 law already changed. The strongest argument on each side.

More than nine million federal student loan borrowers were in default in June 2026, holding $234 billion in loans, and another 3.5 million were more than 30 days behind, according to Federal Student Aid. Those numbers explain why fixing student loans is a permanent item in Washington. What people mean by "fixing" varies widely, though, and the 2025 budget law already settled some of the arguments while opening others.
Below are seven ideas that come up again and again, from economists, borrower advocates, colleges and lawmakers, with the strongest case for and against each. Some are already partly law. None is free of trade-offs.
Federal loans in trouble, June 2026
1. Set interest rates differently
Federal rates are set each July from the May auction of the 10-year Treasury note, plus a fixed add-on. For 2026–27 that produced 6.52 percent for undergraduates, 8.07 percent for graduate students and 9.07 percent for PLUS loans, according to Federal Student Aid. Proposals range from smaller add-ons to rates pegged to the government's own borrowing cost to zero interest.
Take a $30,000 undergraduate balance on a 10-year schedule. At 6.52 percent, the payment is about $341 a month and total interest about $10,900. Cut the rate by two points to 4.52 percent and the payment falls to about $311, with interest of about $7,340. At 2 percent, the payment is about $276 and interest about $3,120. Rates matter, but they change the monthly bill less than most people expect: the $30,000 itself is the bigger number.
For: lower rates reduce the gap between what students borrow and what they repay, and they help most where balances grow because payments do not cover interest. Against: lower rates cost the Treasury, deliver the largest dollar benefit to people with the largest balances (often graduate borrowers with high future incomes), and do little for a borrower whose problem is a payment they cannot afford at any rate.
2. Replace the maze with one income-driven plan
For years borrowers chose among the standard plan, graduated and extended plans, and four income-driven plans with different formulas and forgiveness timelines. Confusion was a real cost: borrowers ended up in plans that did not qualify for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), or paid more than they had to.
The 2025 law moved in this direction. The Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP), open since July 1, 2026, ties payments to adjusted gross income with a $10 minimum and a reduction for each dependent, and forgives the rest after 360 qualifying payments, as the Congressional Research Service describes. New loans from that date can use only RAP or a tiered standard plan, and Pay As You Earn (PAYE) and income-contingent repayment are being phased out by July 2028.
For: one income-based plan is easier to understand, to administer and to get right, and it keeps payments tied to what a borrower earns. Against: critics argue RAP sets payments higher than the SAVE plan it replaced for many low- and middle-income borrowers and stretches forgiveness to 30 years. Others say the simplification is incomplete as long as older borrowers keep legacy plans. Our guide to choosing a repayment plan shows how the current options compare.
A related fight is over taxes. The temporary rule that made income-driven forgiveness tax-free expired at the end of 2025, so a borrower who has $50,000 forgiven after 20 or 25 years can now owe federal income tax on that amount in the year it is canceled. Some lawmakers want the exclusion restored permanently, arguing that a tax bill at the end of decades of payments defeats the purpose of the plan. Others see the forgiven amount as income like any other. Public Service Loan Forgiveness and death and disability discharges remain tax-free either way.
3. Lend less: cap what students and parents can borrow
The argument is that unlimited federal credit lets colleges raise prices and leaves students with debts their degrees cannot support. Until 2026, graduate students and parents could borrow up to the full cost of attendance through PLUS loans.
The 2025 law ended Grad PLUS for new periods of enrollment starting July 1, 2026, capped graduate borrowing at $20,500 a year and $100,000 in total ($50,000 and $200,000 for professional programs such as law and medicine), and limited Parent PLUS to $20,000 a year and $65,000 per student. Undergraduate limits for students themselves were left where they were, at $31,000 in total for a dependent undergraduate. Some reformers argue the real pressure point is that parents and graduate students could borrow almost without limit, while others argue undergraduate limits are now too low to cover the actual cost of a public four-year degree.
For: caps limit how deep a student can go into federal debt and may slow tuition growth at expensive programs. Against: students who still need the money may turn to private loans with fewer protections, and fields left under the lower graduate cap, nursing among them, argue the limits will shrink an already short workforce. The guide for nurses covers that dispute.
4. Hold colleges accountable for outcomes
If a program's graduates routinely cannot repay, the reasoning goes, it should lose access to federal loans. The 2025 law created an earnings test: programs whose graduates earn too little compared with a benchmark group, such as working adults with only a high school diploma for undergraduate programs, can lose Direct Loan eligibility after failing in two of three years. The Education Department's fact sheet on the accountability rules describes the framework, and the first losses of eligibility are still a few years away.
A stronger version, often called risk-sharing, would make colleges repay part of the losses when former students default.
For: schools control price and quality, so tying federal money to results puts the incentive where the decisions are made. Against: earnings depend on region and field as well as quality, so some valuable low-paying programs could be penalized, and risk-sharing could push schools to avoid students who look like financial risks.
5. Service better: get the basics right
Many borrowers' worst experiences have nothing to do with policy design. Payments get misapplied, counts toward forgiveness are wrong, accounts are lost when loans move between servicers, and applications sit in backlogs. Buyback requests under PSLF and income-driven applications were stuck for months in 2026.
Proposals here are unglamorous: clearer servicer contracts with penalties for errors, a single public record of each borrower's qualifying payments, faster processing, and plain-language notices. A borrower should be able to see, on one screen, how many payments count and what is left.
For: fixing administration costs little relative to the loan portfolio and helps every borrower regardless of which plan Congress chooses. Against: few people argue against better servicing as such; the debate is over money and who runs it, including recurring proposals to move parts of the loan program away from the Education Department.
The borrower's side of that fix is simple: download your payment history from your servicer and your loan details from StudentAid.gov and keep both. If a count is ever disputed, your own records are the fastest way to settle it.
6. Make student loans dischargeable in bankruptcy again
Since 1998 federal student loans can be discharged in bankruptcy only by proving undue hardship in a separate lawsuit within the case, and a 2005 law extended the rule to most private student loans. Proposals to restore ordinary treatment, at least after a waiting period, have been introduced in Congress repeatedly.
For: bankruptcy is the standard safety valve for debts people cannot repay, and its absence leaves some borrowers paying for decades or facing garnishment with no exit. It would also make lenders, especially private ones, more careful. Against: opponents worry that recent graduates with few assets and high future earnings would discharge loans early, and that private lenders would charge more or lend less to students with thin credit.
7. Share the burden: employers and the tax code
Employers already help some borrowers. Under Section 127 of the tax code, an employer can pay up to $5,250 a year toward an employee's student loans or tuition without it counting as taxable income, a rule the 2025 law made permanent and indexed to inflation from 2027. Under SECURE 2.0, employers can also treat student loan payments as if they were retirement contributions and add a matching 401(k) or 403(b) contribution.
Proposals in this area would raise the $5,250 cap, which has not changed since 1986, or extend the tax treatment to more types of help. For how the current benefit works in practice, see asking an employer for loan repayment help.
For: these programs move money directly to borrowers' balances, cost the government relatively little, and give employers a recruiting tool. Against: they help mainly people with jobs at larger employers that offer benefits, so they do the least for the borrowers most likely to struggle.
What about cancellation and free college?
Two big ideas sit outside this list. Broad cancellation of existing balances was tried in 2022 and struck down by the Supreme Court in 2023; our guide to what happened to that plan covers the details, and any new version would need Congress. Tuition-free public college, usually starting with community college, would reduce future borrowing rather than existing debt, and our guide to lowering the cost of college looks at what students can already do. The open question for most of these proposals is the one the 2025 law did not settle: whether the system should lend less, charge less, or forgive more, and who pays for whichever choice is made.
Questions readers ask
What is the most common proposal for fixing student loans?
There is no single favorite. Proposals cluster around three goals: making loans cheaper, making repayment simpler and more affordable, and reducing how much students need to borrow in the first place. Most serious plans combine ideas from more than one group.
Why not make federal student loans interest-free?
Supporters say interest turns a modest loan into a much larger debt and falls hardest on borrowers who repay slowly. Critics answer that zero interest would cost taxpayers a great deal, would mostly help borrowers with large balances, and would remove an incentive to repay early.
Did the 2025 law fix student loans?
It changed a lot but settled little. The law created the Repayment Assistance Plan, capped graduate and parent borrowing, and added an earnings test for college programs. Supporters see these as long-overdue limits; critics argue they raise payments for many borrowers and push some students toward private loans.
Can student loans be discharged in bankruptcy?
Yes, but only by proving undue hardship in a separate court proceeding, a much higher bar than for credit card or medical debt. Several bills over the years have proposed restoring ordinary bankruptcy treatment, and none has passed.
What is risk-sharing for colleges?
Risk-sharing would make colleges pay part of the cost when their former students fail to repay federal loans. The idea is to give schools a financial reason to keep prices and outcomes in line, though critics worry it could lead colleges to avoid enrolling lower-income students.
Would free community college reduce student debt?
It would reduce borrowing for students who would otherwise pay tuition at a two-year college, but community college tuition is already low, so most of the debt problem sits at four-year and graduate programs. Living costs, which tuition-free programs do not cover, are often the bigger expense.
How do employer student loan benefits fit in?
Employers can pay up to $5,250 a year toward an employee's student loans tax-free under Section 127, and that rule is now permanent. It helps workers at employers that offer it, but it does nothing for borrowers whose employers do not.
Why is broad loan cancellation not on this list?
Broad cancellation is a one-time fix for existing balances rather than a change to how the system works, and the Supreme Court ruled in 2023 that the Education Department could not do it on its own. Any future broad cancellation would need an act of Congress.
Sources
Run your own loan through the repayment calculator.
Balance, rate and payment in, payoff date and interest out.
Open repayment calculator

