Independent guidance for the life after borrowing


Forgiveness · 9 min read

Biden Student Loan Forgiveness: What Happened to It and What Is Left

The 2022 one-time cancellation, the Supreme Court ruling, the later attempts, the end of SAVE, and the forgiveness routes still open.

Updated · A Balance Forward guide

The white columns and steps of a federal courthouse under an overcast sky, a few distant figures. AI-generated image.AI

The 2022 plan to cancel up to $10,000 of federal student debt per borrower, or $20,000 for Pell Grant recipients, never canceled a dollar. The Supreme Court struck it down on June 30, 2023, in Biden v. Nebraska. Two follow-up proposals were withdrawn in December 2024, and the SAVE repayment plan that was meant to soften payments was blocked in court and ended in March 2026. What remains for borrowers in late 2026 are the older, narrower forgiveness programs, which did deliver large amounts of relief and still work.

This guide walks through what was promised, what happened at each step, and what it means for your loans today.

The 2022 cancellation plan

$10,000promised per borrower
$20,000for Pell Grant recipients
$0canceled under the plan
Struck down by the Supreme Court in Biden v. Nebraska on June 30, 2023.

What did the 2022 plan promise?

The plan, announced on August 24, 2022, offered one-time cancellation of up to $10,000 for borrowers who earned less than $125,000 a year, or less than $250,000 for married couples filing jointly and heads of household, based on 2020 or 2021 income. Borrowers who had received a Pell Grant could get up to $20,000. It covered federal loans held by the Education Department and disbursed by June 30, 2022, including Parent PLUS and graduate loans. Loans made after that date were excluded, and commercially held Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL) loans were later ruled out unless they had been consolidated by a cutoff date.

The cancellation was capped at the balance. A borrower who owed $8,000 would have had $8,000 canceled, not $10,000.

It would also have been free of federal income tax. The 2021 American Rescue Plan Act had excluded most student loan discharges from federal taxable income through the end of 2025, so the relief would not have created a federal tax bill, although a handful of states signaled at the time that they might tax it. That exclusion has since expired for most types of forgiveness.

An online application opened in October 2022, and millions of borrowers applied within weeks. At the same time, the long payment pause that began in March 2020 was still in place, so for many people the question of what they actually owed was on hold.

Why was it struck down?

Several lawsuits were filed almost immediately. In October 2022 a federal appeals court temporarily blocked the program in a case brought by six states led by Nebraska, and in November a federal judge in Texas declared it unlawful in a separate case brought by two borrowers. The Department stopped taking applications.

The Supreme Court heard both cases in February 2023. In Biden v. Nebraska, decided June 30, 2023, the Court ruled 6 to 3 that at least one state, Missouri, had standing through a state-created loan servicer, and that the HEROES Act did not authorize the plan. The administration had relied on that 2003 law, which allows the Education Secretary to "waive or modify" student loan provisions during a national emergency. The majority held that canceling roughly $430 billion went far beyond modifying anything and would need clear authorization from Congress. The companion case brought by the two Texas borrowers was dismissed for lack of standing.

The legal significance outlasts the plan itself. After that ruling, any broad, across-the-board cancellation would almost certainly need a new law passed by Congress.

What came after the ruling?

On the day of the decision, the administration announced three things: a new attempt at relief under a different law, the Higher Education Act; a new income-driven plan called SAVE; and a 12-month "on-ramp" after payments restarted, during which missed payments would not be reported to credit bureaus.

Payments resumed in October 2023, after Congress ended the pause in the Fiscal Responsibility Act. The rulemaking that followed, often called Plan B, proposed narrower cancellation for specific groups, such as borrowers whose balances had grown above what they originally borrowed because of interest, and borrowers who had been in repayment for decades. A separate proposal targeted borrowers facing financial hardship. Neither was finalized. In December 2024 the Department withdrew both proposals, citing operational challenges.

What happened to SAVE?

SAVE launched in 2023 and quickly became the most popular income-driven plan, with more than seven million enrollees. It cut payments for many borrowers to $0 and stopped balances from growing through unpaid interest.

It also drew lawsuits from states arguing that it was mass cancellation by another name. Courts blocked key parts of the plan in 2024, and enrolled borrowers were placed in a forbearance while the litigation ran. In December 2025 the Education Department and Missouri reached a settlement to end SAVE, and the appeals court directed the lower court to approve it.

The 2025 budget law reshaped what borrowers move to. A new Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP) opened on July 1, 2026, alongside a tiered standard plan, and the older Pay As You Earn (PAYE) and income-contingent plans are closed to new enrollment. Former SAVE borrowers receive a notice from their servicer with a window to pick a plan; those who do not choose are placed on a standard plan, which usually means a higher payment. Months spent in the SAVE forbearance generally did not count toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), though they may be recoverable through PSLF buyback.

If you were on SAVE and have not chosen a new plan, log into StudentAid.gov this week and check which plan your loans are on now and what your next payment will be. The repayment plan comparison shows how RAP, income-based repayment and the standard options differ.

How did the end of the payment pause play out?

The pause that started in March 2020 lasted three and a half years, longer than anyone planned, partly because the administration kept extending it while the cancellation plan was in court. Interest resumed on September 1, 2023, and bills followed in October.

The on-ramp softened the first year. Through September 30, 2024, a missed payment was not reported to credit bureaus and loans were not sent to default, although interest kept accruing. When it ended, the usual consequences came back: delinquency reporting, credit damage after 90 days late, and default after about nine months without payments.

The numbers since then show how many borrowers struggled with the restart. Federal Student Aid data for June 2026 counted more than nine million borrowers in default, with $234 billion in loans, and about 3.5 million more than 30 days behind. Some of those borrowers had planned around $10,000 or $20,000 of cancellation and a $0 SAVE payment, and ended up with neither.

If you are behind, the options are the same ones that existed before 2020: switching to an income-driven plan, requesting a deferment or forbearance, or, for defaulted loans, rehabilitation or consolidation to get back into good standing.

Did anyone actually get loans forgiven?

Yes, through programs that already existed in law. By January 2025, the Education Department had approved more than $180 billion in relief for more than five million borrowers, according to reporting by PBS NewsHour. The main channels were:

  • Public Service Loan Forgiveness, after a temporary waiver and later fixes credited payments that had been wrongly rejected. Before 2021, only about 7,000 borrowers had ever received PSLF.
  • An income-driven repayment account adjustment, which recounted payments and certain periods of forbearance and deferment toward 20- or 25-year forgiveness.
  • Borrower defense and closed school discharges for students whose schools misled them or shut down.
  • Total and permanent disability discharges, including automatic discharges identified through Social Security data.

These were targeted programs with eligibility rules, not one-time grants. That is why they survived legal challenges that the broad plan did not.

A worked example: what the plan would have meant

Take a borrower with a $25,000 Direct Loan balance at a 5.5 percent average rate who had received a Pell Grant and qualified on income.

A worked example: what the plan would have meant
Scenario Balance Monthly payment (10-year standard) Total paid
With $20,000 canceled $5,000 about $54 about $6,500
Without cancellation $25,000 about $271 about $32,560

The difference is roughly $26,000 over ten years, or about $217 a month. That gap is what millions of borrowers had budgeted around in 2022 and 2023, and it is why the end of the plan, followed by the end of SAVE, hit household budgets hard.

Where does forgiveness stand now?

There is no broad cancellation program and none pending. What exists is a set of narrower routes, each with clear rules:

  • PSLF cancels the remaining Direct Loan balance after 120 qualifying payments in government or nonprofit work, tax-free. RAP payments count, and an employer-eligibility rule scheduled for July 2026 was vacated by two federal courts before it took effect. Our PSLF guide covers the details.
  • Income-driven forgiveness cancels what remains after 20 or 25 years on income-based repayment, or 30 years (360 qualifying payments) on RAP. Discharges from January 1, 2026 are federally taxable again, because the temporary exclusion in the 2021 American Rescue Plan Act expired and was not extended.
  • Teacher Loan Forgiveness pays up to $17,500 for eligible teachers after five years in a low-income school, depending on subject. The guide to student loan forgiveness for teachers compares it with PSLF.
  • Disability, death, closed school and borrower defense discharges remain available, and death and disability discharges stay tax-free under the 2025 law.

The tax point deserves attention if you expect income-driven forgiveness in the next few years. A borrower who has $40,000 forgiven after 25 years could face a federal tax bill on that amount as income, unless they qualify for the insolvency exclusion. Setting money aside, or checking whether PSLF is a realistic alternative, is cheaper than being surprised.

The broader history of how federal lending reached this point is in our guide to the history of student loans, and the Forgiveness section collects the program-by-program guides. For most borrowers in 2026, the useful step is checking which of these programs their job and loan type already qualify them for.

Questions readers ask

Did anyone receive money from the 2022 forgiveness plan?

No. Applications opened in October 2022, but lower courts blocked the program within weeks, and no debt was canceled under it before the Supreme Court struck it down in June 2023.

Why did the Supreme Court strike down the plan?

In Biden v. Nebraska, decided June 30, 2023, the Court ruled 6 to 3 that the HEROES Act, which lets the Education Secretary waive or modify loan provisions during a national emergency, did not authorize canceling roughly $430 billion in student debt. The majority held that a program of that size needed clear authorization from Congress.

What was the plan B after the Supreme Court ruling?

The administration started a new rulemaking under the Higher Education Act and proposed targeted relief for groups such as borrowers whose balances had grown above what they first borrowed, and later for borrowers facing hardship. Both proposals were withdrawn in December 2024 before they were finalized.

Is the SAVE plan still available?

No. SAVE was blocked in court in 2024 and ended in March 2026. Borrowers who were enrolled receive a notice from their servicer and a window to choose another plan, and those who do not choose are moved to a standard plan.

Did any borrowers get loans forgiven under the Biden administration?

Yes. Through existing programs such as Public Service Loan Forgiveness, income-driven repayment adjustments, borrower defense and disability discharge, the Education Department approved more than $180 billion in relief for more than five million borrowers by January 2025.

Is student loan forgiveness taxable in 2026?

It depends on the program. PSLF, death and disability discharges remain excluded from federal income tax, while forgiveness at the end of an income-driven plan became federally taxable again for discharges from January 1, 2026, because the temporary exclusion expired.

Will there be another broad student loan forgiveness program?

Nothing of the kind exists or is pending as of November 2026. Any broad cancellation would now almost certainly need an act of Congress, given the 2023 ruling.

What forgiveness can I still get in 2026?

The main routes are PSLF after 120 qualifying payments in public service, forgiveness at the end of an income-driven plan, Teacher Loan Forgiveness, total and permanent disability discharge, closed school discharge and borrower defense. Each has its own eligibility rules on StudentAid.gov.

Sources

Run your own loan through the repayment calculator.

Balance, rate and payment in, payoff date and interest out.

Open repayment calculator