Independent guidance for the life after borrowing


Repayment · 10 min read

The Best Way to Repay Federal Student Loans, Plan by Plan

The federal repayment plans open in late 2026, and why the avalanche order beats the snowball on three real-looking loans.

Updated · A Balance Forward guide

A desk with a printed spreadsheet partly covered by a ruler and a pencil, a calculator beside it. AI-generated image.AI

Take three federal loans worth $40,000 in total and $200 a month you can spare beyond the minimums. Send that $200 to the highest-rate loan first and you finish in 74 months with about $9,050 in interest; send it to the smallest balance first and you finish in 76 months with about $10,160. For most borrowers who expect to repay in full, the best way to repay federal student loans is the plainest one: pick the shortest plan you can sustain, then aim every extra dollar at the highest interest rate.

That rule has two exceptions, and both have to do with plans rather than arithmetic. If your income is low relative to your debt, or you work toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness, an income-driven plan can cost less in the end because part of the balance is forgiven. And since July 2025 the menu of plans has changed more than at any point in a decade.

$40,000 in three loans, three ways

Minimums only
$466/mo · 120 payments
Avalanche, +$200 a month
$666/mo · 74 payments
Snowball, +$200 a month
$666/mo · 76 payments
Loans at 4.99%, 6.53% and 8.08%. The avalanche order saves about $1,106 over the snowball.

Which repayment plans exist at the end of 2026?

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed in July 2025, rebuilt federal repayment around two plans for new borrowing and a shrinking list for everyone else. What you can choose depends on one date: whether any of your Direct Loans was first disbursed on or after July 1, 2026. A consolidation loan made after that date counts as new borrowing.

Which repayment plans exist at the end of 2026?
Your situation Plans you can use Forgiveness path
All loans disbursed before July 1, 2026 10-year standard, graduated, extended, Income-Based Repayment (IBR), RAP (PAYE and Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) only until June 30, 2028) IBR, RAP, PSLF on qualifying plans
Any loan disbursed on or after July 1, 2026 Tiered Standard or RAP, for all of your Direct Loans RAP after 360 payments; PSLF through RAP
Parent PLUS with a new loan from July 1, 2026 Tiered Standard only None

The plans above come from the NASFAA summary of the July 2026 repayment plan options, which follows the Department of Education's final rule published in the Federal Register on May 1, 2026.

The fixed plans

The legacy 10-year standard plan sets one payment that clears the loan in 120 months. Graduated starts lower and rises every two years, still inside roughly 10 years. Extended stretches the term to as long as 25 years for borrowers with more than $30,000 in Direct Loans, which lowers the bill and sharply raises the interest.

Borrowers with new loans get the Tiered Standard plan instead. The term depends on your total Direct Loan balance when you enter repayment: under $25,000 is 10 years, $25,000 to $49,999 is 15 years, $50,000 to $99,999 is 20 years, and $100,000 or more is 25 years.

The income-driven plans

The Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP) opened on July 1, 2026. According to the RAP plan description from federal servicer Edfinancial, the yearly payment is a share of your adjusted gross income that climbs one point per $10,000 band, from 1% at $10,001 to $20,000 up to 10% above $100,000, divided by 12. Each dependent takes $50 off the monthly amount, and the minimum is $10. Two features matter for the math: interest your payment does not cover is waived, and if your payment knocks less than $50 off principal, the Department adds a matching principal payment. Whatever is left after 360 qualifying payments is forgiven.

Income-Based Repayment (IBR) remains available to borrowers with pre-July 2026 loans. Newer borrowers pay 10% of discretionary income with forgiveness after 20 years; those with loans from before July 2014 pay 15% over 25 years. Pay As You Earn (PAYE) and ICR are winding down, and anyone on them has to move before July 1, 2028.

SAVE is gone. A court order ended the plan on March 10, 2026, and enrolled borrowers received servicer notices giving them 90 days to pick a new plan. If you were on SAVE and have not chosen, that is the first thing to settle; the restart timeline for SAVE borrowers covers what happens next.

Does forgiveness change the math?

It can, which is why a shorter plan is not automatically best for everyone.

Say a borrower owes $120,000 and earns $55,000. On RAP the payment is 5% of income, about $229 a month, far less than the interest on that balance. Because unpaid interest is waived on RAP, the balance does not grow, and after 30 years the remainder is forgiven. Paying aggressively in that case only shrinks the forgiven amount. For a borrower who owes $25,000 on the same income, the picture flips: the balance is small enough to clear in a few years, so forgiveness is never reached and every dollar of interest avoided is a real saving.

One cost belongs on the forgiveness side of the ledger. The federal tax exclusion for income-driven forgiveness ran out at the end of 2025, so a balance forgiven in 2026 or later can be taxed as income. Public Service Loan Forgiveness is still tax-free at the federal level, and its rules are in our guide to PSLF and the 2026 employer rule.

A useful test: if your total federal debt is lower than your annual income, plan to repay in full and optimize for interest. If it is well above your income and you have decades of payments ahead, compare the forgiveness route first.

Avalanche or snowball: the worked example

Here is the example from the opening in full. The rates are in the range federal loans have carried in recent years. The minimum payments are what each loan would need to clear in 10 years.

Avalanche or snowball: the worked example
Loan Balance Rate 10-year minimum
A $6,000 4.99% $63.61
B $14,000 6.53% $159.18
C $20,000 8.08% $243.50
Total $40,000 $466.29

Paying only the minimums, the borrower clears everything in 120 months and pays about $15,955 in interest. Adding $200 a month, for a total of $666.29, changes the outcome depending on where the extra goes.

Avalanche order sends the $200 to loan C, the 8.08% loan. C is gone in month 54, B in month 70 and A in month 74. Total interest: about $9,054.

Snowball order sends it to loan A, the smallest. A disappears in month 24, which is the whole appeal. B follows in month 55, and C, still charging 8.08% the whole time, lasts until month 76. Total interest: about $10,160. Which method suits your temperament, and not only your balance, is the subject of your student loan repayment personality.

The difference is roughly $1,106 and two months. It would be larger with a wider rate spread, and smaller if all three loans carried similar rates. Mathematically the avalanche never loses. The snowball's case is behavioral: a borrower who quits after a year of seeing no loan vanish would do better with the snowball than with an abandoned avalanche.

Federal servicers do not always send extra money where you want it. Unless you give instructions, an overpayment may be spread across all loans or used to push back your next due date. Our guide to how payment allocation works explains how to direct it at one loan.

When does refinancing fit into the order of attack?

Refinancing replaces a loan with a private one at a new rate. For private loans you already have, it is often the single biggest saving available, and it slots in before any extra payments: lower the rate first, then attack.

Federal loans are different. Refinancing them privately ends access to income-driven plans, Public Service Loan Forgiveness, federal deferment and forbearance, and the waived interest on RAP. That trade only makes sense for a borrower with a high, stable income, a balance they will clearly pay off in full, and a private rate meaningfully below the federal one. Federal consolidation is not refinancing: it averages your existing rates, rounded up to the nearest eighth of a point, and it can change which plans you qualify for, since a consolidation loan made after July 1, 2026 counts as new borrowing.

Before you do anything else this week, open the Loan Simulator on studentaid.gov, sign in, and write down three numbers for each loan: balance, rate and first disbursement date. Those three columns decide your plan options and your avalanche order.

What if some of the loans are Parent PLUS?

Parent PLUS loans follow a separate track, and the order of attack has to account for it. They carry the highest federal rate, 9.07% for loans first disbursed between July 1, 2026 and June 30, 2027, plus a 4.228% origination fee on loans disbursed from October 1, 2026. On an avalanche list they almost always sit at the top.

Their plan options are narrow. A parent whose PLUS loans all predate July 1, 2026 can use the 10-year standard, graduated or extended plans, and income-driven repayment only through a consolidation loan made before that date. A parent with a PLUS loan disbursed on or after July 1, 2026 is limited to the Tiered Standard plan, with no income-driven option and no forgiveness path. Parent PLUS loans, and consolidation loans that include them, cannot be repaid under RAP.

New borrowing is capped too: $20,000 a year and $65,000 in total per child for PLUS loans taken out under the new rules. For a family repaying both a student's loans and a parent's PLUS loan, the math usually favors putting spare money on the PLUS loan first, because nothing else in the household's federal debt costs as much.

How should you put the pieces together?

For a borrower repaying in full, the order of operations looks like this:

  1. Enroll in autopay. The federal autopay discount is 1 percentage point through June 30, 2028 for borrowers who enroll by December 31, 2026, up from the usual 0.25 point.
  2. Choose the shortest fixed plan whose payment you can carry without skipping retirement contributions or an emergency cushion.
  3. Refinance private loans if a lower rate is available.
  4. Send every extra dollar to the highest-rate loan, with written instructions to the servicer.
  5. When that loan is gone, roll its payment into the next-highest rate.

For a borrower aiming at forgiveness, the steps are shorter: pick the income-driven plan with the lowest payment, recertify income on time every year, and put spare money into savings or retirement instead of the loans. To compare the forgiveness route with repaying in full, use the Loan Simulator on studentaid.gov; our repayment calculator covers the repay-in-full side.

The hardest case sits between the two: a balance roughly equal to one or two years of income, with a career that may or may not stay in public service. That borrower should first estimate how many of the next ten years will be spent at a qualifying employer, then pick an order.

Questions readers ask

Which federal repayment plan costs the least overall?

For a borrower who can afford it, the shortest fixed plan costs the least, because interest has the fewest months to run. On legacy loans that is the 10-year standard plan; on loans first disbursed from July 1, 2026, it is the Tiered Standard term that matches your balance. Income-driven plans lower the monthly bill but usually raise the total paid unless forgiveness wipes out a large remainder.

Is the avalanche method always better than the snowball?

On pure arithmetic, yes: sending extra money to the highest-rate loan first always produces the same or lower total interest. The snowball can still be the right choice for someone who will only stick with a plan if a loan disappears quickly. The gap grows with the spread between your highest and lowest rates.

Can I still enroll in SAVE?

No. A court order ended the SAVE plan on March 10, 2026, and borrowers who were enrolled are being moved to other plans. Servicers sent notices giving each borrower 90 days to choose a new plan, with IBR and RAP the main income-driven options.

What is the Repayment Assistance Plan?

RAP is the income-driven plan that opened on July 1, 2026. Payments are 1% to 10% of adjusted gross income depending on the income band, minus $50 a month per dependent, with a $10 minimum. Unpaid monthly interest is waived, and any balance left after 360 qualifying payments is forgiven.

What happens to PAYE and ICR?

Both are being phased out. Borrowers still on PAYE or ICR must move to another eligible plan before July 1, 2028, or they will be placed on one by the Department of Education.

Should I refinance federal loans to get a lower rate?

Only if you are certain you will never need income-driven payments, Public Service Loan Forgiveness, or federal deferment and forbearance. A private refinance replaces the federal loan, so those protections are gone for good. Private loans you already have are a different matter and are often worth refinancing when rates drop.

Do I pay tax on income-driven forgiveness?

The temporary federal exclusion for income-driven forgiveness expired at the end of 2025, so forgiveness granted from 2026 onward can count as taxable income. Public Service Loan Forgiveness remains tax-free at the federal level. State rules vary.

How do I find out which plans my loans qualify for?

Log in to studentaid.gov and use the Loan Simulator, which reads your actual loans and shows estimated payments under each plan you can use. The key dividing line is whether any of your loans was first disbursed on or after July 1, 2026.

Does paying extra on a loan on an income-driven plan make sense?

Only if you expect to pay the loan off in full anyway. If you are working toward forgiveness, extra payments shrink the amount that would have been forgiven, so the money does more good elsewhere.

Sources

Run your own loan through the repayment calculator.

Balance, rate and payment in, payoff date and interest out.

Open repayment calculator