At Work · 8 min read
What Student Loan Benefits Actually Cost an Employer, Worked Out
A 25-person example of what a student loan benefit costs, what Section 127 saves in payroll tax, and where the tax deduction math often goes wrong.

A company that gives 25 employees $100 a month toward their student loans spends $30,000 a year on contributions. Add an assumed administration fee and the gross bill is about $31,800, and that is close to what student loan benefits actually cost an employer before any savings. The interesting part is what that $31,800 buys compared with the obvious alternative, a raise, and how quickly it is offset if it keeps one person from leaving.
The model below uses round numbers you can swap for your own. It is a planning sketch, not tax advice; a payroll provider or accountant should confirm the treatment for your entity type and state.
25 employees, $100 a month
The gross cost: contributions plus administration
Start with three inputs: how many people will use the benefit, how much each gets, and what it costs to run.
For the example, assume a company with 60 employees, 40 of them eligible after a waiting period, and 25 of those with student loans who enroll. Each participant receives a flat $100 a month. Assume administration runs $6 per participant per month. That fee is an assumption for illustration; providers price differently, and some employers run small programs through payroll themselves.
- Contributions: 25 × $100 × 12 = $30,000
- Administration: 25 × $6 × 12 = $1,800
- Gross annual cost: $31,800
Participation is the number most likely to be wrong. Only borrowers can use a direct-payment benefit, so a workforce of recent graduates and licensed professionals will enroll at a much higher rate than one where few people went to college. This week, before you budget anything, send a two-question anonymous survey: do you have student loans, and roughly what do you pay each month? The answers set the size of the program better than any industry average.
What Section 127 saves compared with a raise
Payments made under a Section 127 educational assistance program, up to $5,250 per employee per year, are not wages. That has two effects. The employer owes no Social Security and Medicare tax on them, and the employee owes no income or payroll tax.
On the employer's side the saving is simple: 7.65% of $30,000 is $2,295 a year that would have been due if the same money went out as salary.
The employee's side is larger. Suppose each participant is in the 22% federal bracket and pays 7.65% for Social Security and Medicare. A $1,200 raise leaves $1,200 × (1 − 0.22 − 0.0765) = $844.20 after tax. To put a full $1,200 toward the loan through salary instead, the employer would have to pay a gross raise of about $1,705.76, plus its own 7.65% payroll tax, for a total of $1,836.25 per person.
Swipe the table
| Way of delivering $1,200 a year to each borrower's loan | Cost per employee | Cost for 25 employees |
|---|---|---|
| Section 127 payment (plus $72 admin) | $1,272.00 | $31,800 |
| Taxable raise large enough to net $1,200 | $1,836.25 | about $45,906 |
Delivering the same value to the employee through Section 127 costs about $14,100 less a year in this example. That gap, not the corporate deduction, is the tax advantage of the benefit. State income tax and unemployment insurance would widen it slightly; the example ignores both. IRS Publication 15-B lists the plan conditions that must be met for the exclusion to hold, including a written plan and no option to take cash instead.
Where the deduction math goes wrong
Many cost estimates for these programs subtract a "tax deduction" from the gross cost, sometimes worked out as $5,250 times a corporate tax rate, and present the result as a saving unique to student loan benefits. It is not unique. Contributions are generally deductible as a business expense, but so is every dollar of salary. Compared with paying the same money as wages, the deduction changes nothing.
It does change the after-tax cost, and it is fair to show that. For a C corporation at the 21% federal rate, the $31,800 gross program costs about $31,800 × 0.79 = $25,122 after the deduction. A raise of equal size would get the same treatment. Pass-through businesses depend on the owners' own rates. Just do not count the deduction twice: once as a deduction and again as a reason the benefit beats salary.
The 401(k) match alternative
Since plan years beginning in 2024, an employer may also match employees' student loan payments with contributions to the retirement plan, under Section 110 of the SECURE 2.0 Act. The IRS guidance in Notice 2024-63 covers eligibility, certification and testing.
The cost profile is different. An employer that already matches 401(k) contributions only pays more for employees who were not taking the full match, typically because loan payments left nothing to save. Say 10 of the 25 borrowers contribute nothing to the plan, each earns $60,000, and the plan matches 100% up to 4% of pay. If each pays at least $2,400 a year toward loans, the new cost is 10 × $2,400 = $24,000 a year. Employer matching contributions are not subject to Social Security and Medicare tax either, and they follow the plan's vesting schedule, so some of the money returns to the plan if employees leave early.
The choice between the two is partly about cost and partly about who you are trying to help. A direct payment shortens loans. A match builds retirement savings and treats savers and borrowers alike. The trade-offs between them are set out in our guide to how employer student loan benefits work.
The offset: turnover
The cost that a loan benefit can reduce is turnover. Gallup estimates that replacing an employee costs between one-half and two times their annual salary, counting recruiting, onboarding and lost output, and describes even that range as conservative.
Put that next to the example. If the participants earn an average of $65,000, the low end of Gallup's range puts the cost of replacing one of them at $32,500. The program's gross cost is $31,800. Keeping one participant a year who would otherwise have left roughly pays for the whole program, before counting any effect on hiring.
That is a break-even, not a promise. Whether the benefit changes anyone's decision to stay depends on how big it is relative to their balance, whether it grows with tenure, and what competitors offer. A design that raises the monthly amount each year of service, or that vests over time, is built to do exactly that job. For the evidence on what employees say about such benefits, see how student loan benefits are affecting recruitment and retention.
Costs people forget
A few items do not show up in the headline figure.
Growth. If a program is popular, enrollment rises as new hires join, and a flat budget becomes a per-head cap. Decide in advance whether you will cap total spending or let it grow with headcount.
Tenure tiers. A program that starts at $50 a month and rises by $50 each year to $250 costs far more in year five than in year one. Model at least three years. With 25 participants who all stay, that design costs $50 × 12 × 25 = $15,000 in year one, $30,000 in year two and $45,000 in year three, rising to $75,000 a year once everyone reaches $250. Real turnover pulls those figures down, because new hires restart at $50, but the direction is clear: a tiered program that works as intended gets more expensive precisely because people stay. At $250 a month, each long-tenure employee receives $3,000 a year, still well inside the $5,250 limit.
Taxable overflow. If an employee also uses tuition reimbursement, the two share the $5,250 limit. Every dollar above it is taxable wages, and the payroll tax savings disappear on that portion.
Indexing. The $5,250 limit is set to rise with inflation for tax years beginning after 2026, according to IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32. An employer that pegs its benefit to "the maximum" will see costs rise automatically from 2027.
Administration in house. Running payments through payroll avoids a vendor fee but adds staff time: verifying that each loan is a qualified education loan, sending payments to many servicers, and keeping records for an audit.
Communication. A benefit that employees do not know about is cheap and useless at the same time. Budget a little staff time each year to explain it at onboarding and during open enrollment, and to remind participants how to submit proof of their loans.
A quick way to estimate your own number
The model reduces to a few multiplications. Multiply expected participants by the monthly amount and by 12 for contributions. Add administration. Multiply the contributions by 7.65% for the payroll tax you avoid compared with paying salary. Then compare the gross figure with the low end of Gallup's turnover range for one employee at your average salary.
If one prevented departure covers the program, the question is no longer whether you can afford it but how to design it so it actually keeps people. If it takes three or four, a smaller benefit, a tenure tier, or a retirement match aimed at borrowers may fit the budget better. Employees who want to make the case from their side will find the arguments in our guide on asking an employer to help with student loans, and the guide to the student loan repayment benefit for employers covers the tax rules and plan design.
Questions readers ask
How much do employers usually contribute to student loans?
There is no standard amount. Many programs pay a flat monthly sum such as $100 or $200, and some raise it with tenure. Anything up to $5,250 per employee per year can be paid tax-free under Section 127, which is why few programs go above that.
Do employers save payroll tax by paying student loans through Section 127?
Yes. Payments within the $5,250 limit are not wages, so the employer does not owe its 7.65% share of Social Security and Medicare tax on them. On $1,200 a year per employee that is about $92 saved per person compared with paying the same amount as salary.
Are student loan contributions tax-deductible for the business?
Generally yes, as an ordinary business expense, but so are wages. The deduction therefore does not make a loan benefit cheaper than a raise of the same size. The real tax advantage is the payroll tax the employer avoids and the income tax the employee avoids.
What does it cost to offer a 401(k) match on student loan payments?
The extra cost comes only from employees who were not already receiving the full match through their own retirement contributions. Employer matching contributions to a 401(k) are not subject to Social Security and Medicare tax. Plan administrators may charge for adding the feature and handling the annual certifications.
How many employees will actually use a student loan benefit?
Only employees with student loans can use a direct-payment benefit, so participation depends on the workforce. An anonymous survey before launch is the most reliable way to size the budget. Employers that hire many recent graduates or licensed professionals tend to see the highest uptake.
Can a student loan benefit pay for itself through lower turnover?
It can, if it keeps even a few people from leaving. Gallup estimates that replacing an employee costs between one-half and two times their annual salary. For a mid-sized team, retaining one additional employee a year can cover a modest program.
What happens if an employer pays more than $5,250?
The amount above $5,250 is taxable wages for the employee and subject to payroll taxes for both sides. Tuition assistance under the same plan counts toward the same limit, so an employee using both can reach the cap quickly.
Will the $5,250 limit go up?
The 2025 tax law indexed the limit to inflation for tax years beginning after 2026, so the first adjustment is expected in 2027. The IRS publishes the adjusted figure in its annual inflation revenue procedure.
Sources
Run your own loan through the repayment calculator.
Balance, rate and payment in, payoff date and interest out.
Open repayment calculator

