Independent guidance for the life after borrowing


Repayment · 9 min read

Why Your Student Loan Balance Keeps Growing, and How to Stop It

Four mechanisms make student loan balances grow, from forbearance to payments below interest. How each works and how to shut it down.

Updated · A Balance Forward guide

A kitchen counter with a calculator, a mug and a folded paper statement in soft focus. AI-generated image.AI

A $40,000 federal loan at 6.8% that sits in forbearance for two years picks up $5,440 in interest: $40,000 × 0.068 × 2. No payments were missed, nothing went to collections, and the borrower now owes $45,440. That is how most student loan balances grow. Interest keeps running whenever the payment is paused or too small to cover it, and a few specific events turn that unpaid interest into principal.

Two years of forbearance

$40,000owed when the pause starts
$45,440owed two years later
6.8% simple interest: $40,000 × 0.068 × 2 = $5,440. No payment was missed.

How does student loan interest build up?

Federal student loans charge simple daily interest. Each day, the servicer multiplies your principal by the annual rate and divides by 365. On $40,000 at 6.8%, that is about $7.45 a day, or roughly $227 a month.

Simple interest grows in a straight line, which is better for borrowers than compounding. The trouble starts when that interest is not paid. It piles up as outstanding interest, and every payment you make goes to it before any of the principal. A borrower can pay for months and see the principal barely move.

The four ways that happens are covered below, from most to least common.

Pauses: forbearance and deferment

Forbearance stops payments but not interest. Every loan accrues during it, including subsidized loans. That is the example in the opening, and it is also what happened to millions of borrowers on SAVE: interest on loans in the SAVE litigation forbearance resumed on August 1, 2025, more than a year before most of them had a new plan.

Deferment is gentler on subsidized loans, whose interest the Department of Education pays during deferment, as the studentaid.gov comparison of subsidized and unsubsidized loans explains. Unsubsidized and PLUS loans still accrue.

Forbearance has one more cost in 2026: the temporary 1-point federal autopay discount stops while a loan is in forbearance or deferment.

The fix. If you need a lower payment, an income-driven plan is almost always better than a pause, because payments count and interest is controlled. If you must pause, pay the interest each month if you can, even when no payment is required. On the $40,000 loan above, that is about $227 a month, and it keeps the balance flat.

Payments that are smaller than the interest

On an income-driven plan, the payment is based on income rather than the balance. When the payment is below the monthly interest, the gap accrues as unpaid interest.

The worked example on IBR

Take a $45,000 loan at 7% on Income-Based Repayment. Monthly interest is $45,000 × 0.07 ÷ 12 = $262.50. If the borrower's Income-Based Repayment (IBR) payment is $150, each month leaves $112.50 unpaid. Over a year, that is $1,350 of outstanding interest on top of a principal that has not moved at all. Five years at the same income adds $6,750.

On IBR, the government covers unpaid interest on subsidized loans only, and only for the first three consecutive years. Everything else stays on the account.

The same borrower on RAP

The Repayment Assistance Plan, open since July 1, 2026, handles the same gap differently. According to the RAP plan description from federal servicer Edfinancial, interest left unpaid after an on-time monthly payment is subsidized, so it does not accrue. And if the payment cuts principal by less than $50, the Department adds a matching principal payment, capped at the amount you paid.

So on RAP, the borrower paying $150 against $262.50 of interest sees the interest gap waived and receives a principal credit, up to $50 a month or $600 a year. The balance goes down, slowly, instead of up.

The fix. For a borrower whose income-driven payment is below the interest, RAP is usually the better plan on this measure alone. One caution: moving from IBR to any other plan capitalizes the unpaid interest built up on IBR. Check the outstanding interest figure before you switch, and if it is large, consider paying some of it first.

Capitalization: when interest becomes principal

Capitalization adds unpaid interest to principal. After that, you pay interest on the old interest, and the balance grows faster than a straight line.

For federal Direct Loans, rules that took effect on July 1, 2023 removed most capitalization events. The end of the grace period, the end of most forbearances, entering repayment for the first time and default no longer capitalize interest. The annual capitalization that used to happen on Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) is gone too.

A few triggers remain, several because they are written into the Higher Education Act rather than regulation:

  1. The end of a deferment on an unsubsidized or PLUS loan.
  2. Leaving Income-Based Repayment for another plan.
  3. Missing the IBR income recertification, which moves the payment up to the standard amount.
  4. Consolidating loans with outstanding interest, which becomes part of the new loan's principal.

Private loans and older commercially held Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL) loans follow their promissory notes. Many still capitalize at the end of school, grace, deferment and forbearance.

The fix. Pay off outstanding interest before any of those events. Put the IBR recertification date in your calendar a month ahead. If you are about to leave a deferment on an unsubsidized loan, a payment equal to the accrued interest just before it ends stops the capitalization entirely.

Your servicer account shows two numbers for each loan: principal and outstanding interest. If the second is above zero, that is the amount at risk from the next capitalization event, and paying it down is the quickest way to stop the balloon from growing.

Defaults and missed payments

A loan that goes into default can pick up collection costs, and the borrower loses access to most repayment plans until the loan is brought back into good standing. Federal loans generally default after 270 days without a payment. Missed payments also stop the autopay discount and can be reported to credit bureaus once they are 90 days late.

Defaulted loans also sit outside the protections described above. The RAP interest waiver and the autopay discount do not apply until the loan is out of default, so the balance keeps growing at the full rate in the meantime.

The fix. If a payment is unaffordable, switch to RAP before the due date. Its minimum is $10 a month. A loan already in default can be brought back through rehabilitation or consolidation, after which plan options return.

How can you tell which mechanism is behind your balance?

Your servicer statement usually answers it, if you know where to look. Compare three figures across two statements a year apart: principal, outstanding interest and total paid.

If principal stayed the same and outstanding interest rose, your payment is below the interest charged. That points to an income-driven payment on IBR, or to a pause. If principal itself went up in a single jump, a capitalization event happened, and the date of the jump will match the end of a deferment, a plan change out of IBR, a missed recertification or a consolidation. If both figures look normal but the total seems high, check the interest rate shown on the account. A rate without the autopay discount, or a consolidation rate rounded up from your old loans, explains slow progress without any balloon at all.

You can also run a daily-interest check by hand. Multiply principal by the rate and divide by 365. On $30,000 at 6.5%, that is about $5.34 a day, or around $160 a month. If your monthly payment is lower than that figure, the balance cannot fall on IBR or any fixed plan, no matter how faithfully you pay. That single comparison tells you whether the fix is a different plan or simply more time.

Statements from private lenders follow the same logic, but read the promissory note alongside them. Many private loans capitalize interest at the end of every deferment and forbearance, and some capitalize on a schedule, so the jumps may come more often than on federal loans.

How do you turn a growing balance into a shrinking one?

The sequence for most borrowers is the same:

  • Stop the growth first. Move to a plan where your payment covers the interest, or to RAP, where the shortfall is waived.
  • Clear the outstanding interest before any capitalization event.
  • Then send extra money to principal on the highest-rate loan, with written instructions to the servicer. Making sure it lands there means specifying each loan instead of using auto allocate.

For a borrower who is heading for forgiveness, a growing balance on IBR or RAP is not automatically a loss, because the remainder is cancelled after the required payments. Forgiveness granted from 2026 onward can be taxed as income, though, so a very large forgiven balance carries a cost of its own. Our guide to the best way to repay federal loans helps decide which route fits.

Graduates often find their balance already higher than what they borrowed, because unsubsidized loans accrue during school; the numbers are in our guide to paying loans while still in school. Borrowers coming off the SAVE forbearance have the same issue on a larger scale, and the timeline of the restart shows where their accrued interest came from. For a borrower with $6,000 of outstanding interest and a looming IBR exit, the practical question is how many months of extra payments it would take to clear that figure before the switch.

Questions readers ask

Why is my student loan balance higher than what I borrowed?

Interest has accrued faster than you paid it, usually during school, the grace period, a deferment or a forbearance, or on a payment plan whose monthly amount is below the interest charged. On federal loans, unpaid interest is tracked separately, and some events still add it to principal.

What is capitalized interest?

Capitalization is when unpaid interest is added to your principal balance. From then on you pay interest on that interest, so the loan grows faster. On federal Direct Loans, most capitalization events were removed on July 1, 2023, but a few remain.

When does interest still capitalize on federal loans?

On Direct Loans, the main remaining triggers are the end of a deferment on an unsubsidized loan, leaving Income-Based Repayment, and missing IBR recertification so your payment rises to the standard amount. Consolidation also rolls outstanding interest into the new loan's principal.

Does forbearance make my balance grow?

Yes. Interest keeps accruing on every loan during forbearance, including subsidized loans. On Direct Loans the interest no longer capitalizes when most forbearances end, but you still owe it, and your payments go to it first.

Can an income-driven plan cause my balance to grow?

On IBR, yes, if your payment is less than the monthly interest. On the Repayment Assistance Plan, no: interest your on-time payment does not cover is waived, and a principal match of up to $50 applies when your payment cuts principal by less than that.

How do I see how much unpaid interest I owe?

Log in to your servicer's website. The account summary usually shows principal and outstanding interest as separate lines for each loan, and your studentaid.gov dashboard shows the same figures for federal loans.

Should I pay off the interest or the principal first?

Servicers apply payments to outstanding interest before principal, so you cannot skip the interest. Once it is cleared, every extra dollar goes to principal, which is what actually reduces future interest.

Do private student loans capitalize interest?

Often, yes. Private loans follow their promissory notes, and many capitalize interest at the end of school, grace, deferment or forbearance. Read the note or ask the lender when capitalization occurs on your loan.

Will my balance be forgiven if it keeps growing on an income-driven plan?

On IBR and RAP, any remainder is forgiven after the required number of qualifying payments, so a growing balance is not always a loss. Forgiveness granted from 2026 onward can be taxable, so a large forgiven amount may come with a tax bill.

Sources

Run your own loan through the repayment calculator.

Balance, rate and payment in, payoff date and interest out.

Open repayment calculator